Post-quantum migration for on-chain identity: an anchored
Sharing an approach we’ve been building and would like scrutiny on. It’s aimed at the narrow but real problem of migrating the signature layer of on-chain / agent identity to post-quantum, and it leans on recomputation rather than trust. The problem. Shor breaks the ECDSA/Schnorr signatures under most of Web3 and most AI-attestation identity. Hashes survive (Grover only halves them). The usual reflex “add a post-quantum signature alongside the classical one” doesn’t actually close it: a forger who derives the classical key just omits the extra signature. A second signature is opt-in from the v
TL;DR
AI models have found key‑recovery attacks in the post‑quantum schemes HAWK and Classic McEliece, leading Project Eleven to launch a hybrid custody platform and prompting Bitcoin to draft a BIP that phases out legacy signatures by 2030. The findings accelerate the need for adaptable, quantum‑resistant security in crypto.
Key facts
- Anthropic’s Claude Mythos discovered a symmetry‑based key‑recovery attack on HAWK in July 2026.
- The attack reduced HAWK‑512’s effective security from 2^150 to 2^108.
- Analyses suggested Classic McEliece’s key‑recovery complexity could be as low as 2^94 operations.
- Germany’s BSI advised against deploying Classic McEliece by early October 2026.
- Project Eleven launched Strongpoint, a hybrid signing custody platform, in October 2026.
- A new Bitcoin BIP proposes phasing out legacy signatures and freezing vulnerable coins after about five years.
- Academic forecasts indicate quantum computers capable of breaking Bitcoin could appear between 2027 and 2030.
On October 19, 2026, Conor Deegan, co‑founder of Project Eleven, warned that artificial‑intelligence models have uncovered exploitable mathematical flaws in two post‑quantum cryptographic schemes, HAWK and Classic McEliece. The AI model Claude Mythos, developed by Anthropic, identified a symmetry‑based key‑recovery attack on HAWK, while separate analyses suggested Classic McEliece’s key‑recovery complexity could be far lower than previously believed. The revelations arrived just weeks before Project Eleven launched its Strongpoint custody platform, which pairs classical and post‑quantum signatures, and they coincided with a new Bitcoin Improvement Proposal that seeks to replace legacy signature schemes with quantum‑resistant alternatives by 2030.
Background
Post‑quantum cryptography has been pursued for years because quantum computers, once sufficiently powerful, are expected to break widely used encryption and signature algorithms such as ECDSA and Schnorr. The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has been running a multi‑year standardisation process to identify quantum‑resistant signatures, with schemes like HAWK competing for inclusion. Classic McEliece, another candidate, relies on a different hard mathematical problem and has long been considered a safe fallback. In parallel, the digital‑asset community has been preparing for a quantum future: Project Eleven was founded in 2024 to study cryptographic threats to crypto assets, and the Bitcoin ecosystem has begun drafting a BIP that would phase out vulnerable legacy signatures. The BIP, authored by Jameson Lopp and Christian Papathanasiou, notes that about a quarter of Bitcoin’s unspent outputs already expose public keys on‑chain, making those funds especially susceptible to a future quantum adversary. Meanwhile, Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) issued an advisory against deploying Classic McEliece, reflecting growing caution even before any quantum hardware exists. The convergence of AI‑driven cryptanalysis and the looming quantum timeline has forced both custodians and protocol designers to reconsider their security assumptions.
What happened
According to the cryptobriefing report, Anthropic’s AI model Claude Mythos discovered a symmetry‑based key‑recovery attack on HAWK in July 2026. The attack halved HAWK’s effective security, dropping the HAWK‑512 level from 2^150 to 2^108, and led to HAWK’s withdrawal from the NIST round that same month. Project Eleven co‑founder Conor Deegan said the AI findings surfaced within two months before his October 19 remarks. The same report notes that independent analyses later in 2026 suggested Classic McEliece’s key‑recovery complexity could be as low as 2^94 operations, prompting the BSI to advise against its deployment by early October. In response, Project Eleven launched Strongpoint, a custody platform that uses hybrid signing—pairing a classical signature with a post‑quantum one—and modular algorithm integration to swap out compromised schemes without rebuilding the whole system. Meanwhile, Cointelegraph reported that a new Bitcoin Improvement Proposal titled “Post Quantum Migration and Legacy Signature Sunset” was drafted earlier in the week by Jameson Lopp, Christian Papathanasiou and other experts. The BIP proposes phasing out Bitcoin’s legacy ECDSA and Schnorr signatures, freezing coins in vulnerable addresses after about five years, and eventually allowing recovery via special cryptographic methods linked to backup phrases. The proposal cites academic forecasts that quantum computers capable of breaking Bitcoin could appear as early as 2027 to 2030, and it warns that a successful quantum attack would cause significant economic disruption across the ecosystem.
Market impact
The cryptobriefing article does not cite any price movements, but it does note that Project Eleven’s Strongpoint platform was launched in October 2026, signalling a market response to the AI‑driven vulnerabilities. The Cointelegraph piece references that roughly a quarter of Bitcoin’s unspent outputs have already revealed public keys, and another source within the same article mentions about 30% of BTC coins sit in addresses vulnerable to quantum attacks. While no direct trading data is provided, the BIP’s proposal to freeze vulnerable coins after five years could influence investor sentiment, especially for holders of older addresses. The combined effect of AI‑found flaws in candidate post‑quantum schemes and the Bitcoin community’s migration plan suggests a heightened focus on security‑focused custody solutions and a possible shift in capital toward platforms that can offer hybrid or modular cryptographic protections.
Why it matters
The AI‑discovered weaknesses in HAWK and Classic McEliece demonstrate that post‑quantum schemes are no longer only vulnerable to future quantum hardware; they can be compromised today by sophisticated machine‑learning tools. This shortens the timeline for attackers to find exploitable shortcuts, forcing custodians to adopt more resilient designs such as hybrid signing, as Project Eleven has done with Strongpoint. For Bitcoin, the BIP’s phased migration acknowledges that a non‑trivial portion of the supply is already exposed to quantum risk, and it proposes concrete steps to mitigate catastrophic loss before quantum computers become a practical threat. The convergence of AI‑driven cryptanalysis and the impending quantum era means that both digital‑asset custodians and protocol developers must treat security as a moving target, continuously updating algorithms rather than relying on static standards. Failure to adapt could result in key‑recovery attacks that jeopardise private keys, potentially leading to loss of assets and erosion of confidence in blockchain systems.
DeFi Intel’s take
Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.
DeFi Intel's take: the twin pressures of AI‑enabled cryptanalysis and an accelerating quantum horizon suggest that the crypto industry is entering a period of rapid algorithmic turnover. We read Project Eleven’s launch of Strongpoint as a pragmatic response that acknowledges the need for modular, hybrid security architectures. The Bitcoin BIP’s phased approach signals a growing consensus that waiting for quantum hardware to arrive is no longer sufficient; proactive migration is required to protect funds already exposed on‑chain. Together, these developments imply that custodians and protocol teams will likely prioritize flexible cryptographic stacks, and investors may shift toward assets and services that can demonstrate real‑time resilience against both AI and quantum threats.
Sources used for this analysis
- cryptobriefing.com/ai-breaks-post-quantum-hawk-mceliece/
- cointelegraph.com/news/bitcoin-quantum-computing-threat-bip-post-quantum-migration
DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.
Frequently asked questions
What AI model identified the flaw in the HAWK signature scheme?
Anthropic’s Claude Mythos model discovered a symmetry‑based key‑recovery attack on HAWK in July 2026, halving its effective security and prompting its withdrawal from the NIST standardisation round.
Why did Germany’s BSI advise against using Classic McEliece?
Analyses in early 2026 suggested that Classic McEliece’s key‑recovery complexity could be as low as 2^94 operations, far below earlier estimates, leading the BSI to recommend against its deployment.
What does the new Bitcoin BIP propose for vulnerable addresses?
The BIP suggests stopping new transactions to legacy addresses, freezing coins in those addresses after about five years, and eventually allowing recovery through special cryptographic methods linked to a wallet’s backup phrase.
Direct answers
Short answers, written to be quoted.
- What post‑quantum schemes were found vulnerable by AI?
- AI models identified exploitable mathematical flaws in the HAWK digital signature scheme and Classic McEliece, reducing their security levels dramatically.
- How is Project Eleven responding to these vulnerabilities?
- Project Eleven introduced Strongpoint, a custody platform that uses hybrid signing—pairing a classical signature with a post‑quantum one—and modular algorithm integration to swap out compromised schemes.
- What timeline does the Bitcoin BIP set for quantum‑resistant migration?
- The BIP aims to complete the migration by 2030, with an initial phase stopping transactions to vulnerable addresses and a later phase freezing those coins before allowing recovery via special cryptographic methods.
DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Ethereum_magicians.
Discussion
Comments are reviewed before publication.
Want the full article?
Continue reading on Ethereum_magicians →
No comments yet.