DeFi Intel

Kalshi and Polymarket are fighting a 50-state war — DeFi Intel

Twelve states, criminal charges, tribes at the Ninth Circuit, and the CFTC suing states. Inside the federalism war over prediction markets.

TL;DR

Kalshi and Polymarket are fighting state‑level legal challenges that could push bettors offshore, while Hyperliquid’s new outcome contracts generated three times the volume of both incumbents combined, highlighting a shift toward institutional use of prediction markets.

Key facts

  • Hyperliquid’s Bitcoin outcome market generated roughly three times the volume of Polymarket and Kalshi combined.
  • Combined monthly volume for Polymarket and Kalshi reached nearly $24 billion in April.
  • Kalshi holds a 62% market share, up from 55% in January.
  • Polymarket’s second‑largest all‑time market is the 2026 World Cup at $884 million.

Kalshi and Polymarket are locked in a nationwide legal battle as U.S. states move to classify their sports-event contracts as illegal gambling, while a new entrant, Hyperliquid, launched outcome contracts that dwarfed the combined volume of the two incumbents. The clash unfolded in July 2026, with Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour warning that state‑by‑state crackdowns could drive bettors offshore, and Bernstein analysts highlighting the rise of prediction markets as institutional hedging tools. Hyperliquid’s first Bitcoin outcome market generated roughly three times the volume of Polymarket and Kalshi combined, according to Hyperion DeFi CEO Hyunsu Jung.

Background

Prediction markets have long operated under the oversight of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which grants a federal exchange license to designated contract markets (DCMs) like Kalshi. This federal framework is intended to preempt state gambling laws, but recent court decisions have created a split: the Third Circuit upheld Kalshi’s preemption argument in New Jersey, while the Ninth and Sixth Circuits affirmed state authority in other jurisdictions. As a result, Kalshi faces enforcement actions in Nevada, Ohio, Tennessee, Massachusetts, Michigan and Washington, and is litigating in roughly twenty states. At the same time, the sector is attracting institutional attention. Bernstein has added prediction markets to its digital‑assets research coverage, arguing that binary contracts offer macro‑focused funds a cleaner hedge against event risk compared with traditional FX or commodity options. Hyperliquid, a decentralized finance exchange that processes $6 billion in daily derivatives volume, entered the space with its HIP‑4 product, leveraging a shared liquidity layer and institutional partners such as FalconX, Ripple Prime and Anchorage Digital. The launch coincides with heightened activity around the 2026 FIFA World Cup, historically a high‑volume event for prediction markets, and with Blockchain.com filing for CFTC licences to operate its own event‑contract marketplace.

What happened

In early July 2026 Hyperliquid launched its first outcome contracts, beginning with a Bitcoin price market that generated roughly three times the volume of Polymarket and Kalshi combined, Hyunsu Jung told DL News. Jung said the shared liquidity layer proved effective in converting users and that binary markets are the next step for Hyperliquid, which already dominates crypto perpetuals. Bernstein analysts Gautam Chhugani and colleagues noted that the timing of Hyperliquid’s launch aligns with a broader institutional shift toward prediction markets as hedging tools, and they reported combined monthly volumes of Polymarket and Kalshi at nearly $24 billion in April, with Kalshi holding a 62% market share driven largely by sports betting. Meanwhile, Kalshi’s CEO Tarek Mansour warned that a state‑by‑state crackdown would push bettors to offshore platforms lacking any regulatory oversight. He explained that Kalshi operates under a CFTC‑issued federal licence, which it argues preempts state gambling laws, but courts are split: the Third Circuit backed Kalshi in New Jersey, while the Ninth and Sixth Circuits upheld state authority, leading to enforcement actions in Nevada, Ohio, Tennessee, Massachusetts, Michigan and Washington. By late August, at least four states had secured court orders restricting Kalshi’s contracts, and the company is now litigating in about twenty states with support from Coinbase in some challenges. In parallel, Blockchain.com filed applications with the CFTC for a DCM and an FCM licence, aiming to offer its own event‑contract marketplace after announcing a partnership with Polymarket. The CFTC chair, Michael Selig, reiterated the agency’s intent to regulate crypto markets, citing the FTX collapse as a cautionary tale.

Market impact

Hyperliquid’s Bitcoin outcome market generated roughly three times the volume of Polymarket and Kalshi combined, according to Hyunsu Jung. Combined monthly volumes for Polymarket and Kalshi reached nearly $24 billion in April, with Kalshi commanding a 62% market share, up from 55% in January. Sports betting accounts for roughly 72% of Kalshi’s volume, and the 2026 World Cup is Polymarket’s second‑largest market by all‑time volume at $884 million. FalconX launched prime‑brokerage margin financing for Hyperliquid in February, and Ripple Prime cleared over $3 trillion annually while adding Hyperliquid as its first DeFi venue. Anchorage Digital supports custody and staking of Hyperliquid’s HYPE token. Blockchain.com’s potential IPO could value the company at up to $6 billion, with a planned $500 million raise.

Why it matters

The legal split over state versus federal oversight creates uncertainty for regulated prediction‑market operators and could reshape where bettors place their money. Kalshi’s warning that state crackdowns may drive users to offshore platforms underscores the risk of a fragmented market lacking consumer protections. At the same time, institutional interest, highlighted by Bernstein’s coverage and Hyperliquid’s rapid volume growth, suggests that prediction markets are being viewed as efficient hedging instruments for macro‑focused funds. The entry of a high‑volume DeFi player like Hyperliquid, backed by traditional finance partners, intensifies competition and may pressure incumbents to innovate or seek broader regulatory clarity. Blockchain.com’s pursuit of CFTC licences signals that more crypto‑centric firms aim to enter the regulated event‑contract space, potentially expanding retail and institutional access. The outcome of ongoing court cases and the CFTC’s regulatory actions will likely determine whether the U.S. market remains dominated by federally licensed DCMs or fragments into a patchwork of state‑regulated or offshore platforms.

DeFi Intel’s take

Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.

DeFi Intel's take: the convergence of legal uncertainty and rapid institutional adoption suggests the prediction‑market sector is at a crossroads. We read the split in federal appellate rulings as a catalyst for both regulatory consolidation and market migration. The surge in Hyperliquid’s volume, combined with strong backing from prime brokers and custodians, indicates that a shared‑liquidity DeFi model can attract significant capital, potentially outpacing traditional DCMs if regulatory hurdles are eased. Meanwhile, Kalshi’s litigation strategy and its appeal for federal‑level regulation highlight the industry’s desire for a uniform rulebook. If states continue to impose divergent restrictions, the sector may see a shift toward platforms that operate outside U.S. jurisdiction, eroding consumer safeguards. The CFTC’s push for broader crypto regulation, exemplified by Blockchain.com’s licence applications, could either provide the needed clarity or further entrench the split, depending on how quickly the agency moves. Overall, the next few months will likely decide whether prediction markets become a mainstream hedging tool or retreat into fragmented, less regulated niches.

Sources used for this analysis

DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.

Frequently asked questions

What legal challenge is Kalshi facing?

Kalshi is confronting a state‑by‑state crackdown as several states seek to classify its sports‑event contracts as illegal gambling, leading to court orders in Nevada, Massachusetts, Michigan and Washington and litigation in roughly twenty states.

How does Hyperliquid's Bitcoin outcome market compare to Kalshi and Polymarket?

Hyperliquid’s Bitcoin outcome market generated roughly three times the volume of the combined Bitcoin outcome markets on Polymarket and Kalshi, according to Hyperion DeFi CEO Hyunsu Jung.

What is the significance of Bernstein’s coverage of prediction markets?

Bernstein has added prediction markets to its digital‑assets research, arguing that binary contracts offer macro‑focused funds a cleaner hedge against event risk, and it reported combined monthly volumes of Kalshi and Polymarket near $24 billion.

Direct answers

Short answers, written to be quoted.

What advantage does Hyperliquid claim with its shared liquidity layer?
Hyperliquid says the shared liquidity layer efficiently converts users and enables binary markets to dominate crypto perpetuals, as shown by its high‑volume Bitcoin outcome market.
How is the CFTC involved in the prediction‑market debate?
The CFTC issues federal licences for designated contract markets like Kalshi, and Blockchain.com has applied for both a DCM and an FCM licence to launch its own event‑contract marketplace.
Read full article on Crypto_news_dot →

DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Crypto_news_dot.

Entities in this story

Discussion

Comments are reviewed before publication.

No comments yet.

Stay current on entity-tagged crypto news

Get the weekly DeFi Intel brief — entity-graph intelligence covering protocols, tokens and incidents, free to your inbox.