DeFi Intel

MiCA licensing only the beginning as crypto custodians face scrutiny

The only available information is the title, which states that MiCA licensing is 'only the beginning' and that crypto custodians face scrutiny. No further details, quotes, or facts can be extracted from the provided text.

TL;DR

ESMA’s peer‑review found Malta’s MFSA only partially met expectations in authorising a crypto‑asset service provider under MiCA, prompting recommendations for tighter monitoring and supervisory adjustments. The finding highlights challenges in consistent EU crypto licensing and may affect future custodial licences.

Key facts

  • The MFSA only partially met expectations for the CASP authorisation.
  • The European Banking Authority’s Board of Supervisors adopted a coordinated approach for CASP authorisations in December 2024.

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) released a peer‑review report on Thursday that found Malta’s Financial Services Authority (MFSA) had only “partially met expectations” in the authorization of a particular crypto‑asset service provider (CASP). The assessment, part of ESMA’s ongoing scrutiny of national competent authorities under the Markets in Crypto‑Assets Regulation (MiCA), highlights shortfalls in the MFSA’s handling of the licensing process. The review, conducted by ESMA’s ad‑hoc Peer Review Committee (PRC), follows a coordinated approach adopted by the European Banking Authority’s Board of Supervisors in December 2024 and a peer‑review launch in April 2025. The findings raise questions about the robustness of Malta’s crypto‑custody licensing regime.

Background

MiCA, which entered into force on 29 June 2024, represents the European Union’s first comprehensive legal framework for digital assets, aiming to harmonise rules across member states. Under MiCA, each national competent authority (NCA) is responsible for authorising crypto‑asset service providers, including custodians, exchanges and wallet operators. In December 2024, the European Banking Authority’s Board of Supervisors agreed on a coordinated approach for CASP authorisations, signalling a move toward supervisory convergence. ESMA subsequently launched a peer‑review process in April 2025 to assess the MFSA’s performance in authorising and supervising a CASP, with the goal of improving consistency across NCAs. The peer‑review targeted a single Maltese CASP, though the regulator did not disclose its identity. The PRC’s evaluation covered three main areas: supervisory settings and resources, the authorisation process itself, and the subsequent supervisory review and use of powers. While the MFSA was praised for its expertise and staffing levels, the report identified gaps in how material issues pending at the time of authorisation were addressed, prompting recommendations for tighter monitoring and timely adjustments in supervisory practice.

What happened

ESMA’s Peer Review Committee issued a report on Thursday that examined the MFSA’s handling of a CASP authorisation. The PRC noted that the MFSA has built a good level of expertise in the sector and possesses sufficient supervisory resources for CASP authorisations and supervision, fully meeting supervisory settings requirements and largely meeting supervisory review rules. However, the committee concluded that the MFSA only partially met expectations regarding the authorisation of the specific CASP, citing unresolved material issues that were pending at the date of authorisation. The report recommended that the MFSA assess these material issues and adjust supervisory practices in a timely manner. ESMA highlighted that the novelty and inherent risks of CASPs require NCAs to pay particular attention to certain aspects of authorisation. The peer‑review was part of a broader effort initiated after the European Banking Authority’s Board of Supervisors adopted a coordinated approach for CASP authorisations in December 2024 and after ESMA launched the peer‑review in April 2025. The PRC’s visual summary illustrated the MFSA’s performance across assessment areas, showing full compliance in supervisory settings, partial compliance in authorisation, and largely meeting supervisory review standards. The report did not disclose the name of the CASP in question, and XReg consulting partner Nathan Catania told Cointelegraph that without knowing the unresolved issues, it is hard to comment, but he would not expect any revocation or re‑evaluation based on the report.

Market impact

The ESMA report has not triggered any immediate changes to licensing numbers or market prices, as the source does not provide quantitative data on licences issued or revoked. Nevertheless, the scrutiny of Malta’s licensing regime under MiCA may influence investor confidence in Maltese‑based crypto custodians, potentially affecting capital flows into the jurisdiction. The lack of disclosed identity for the CASP means that market participants cannot directly assess exposure to specific entities, but the broader signal of “partial” compliance could prompt custodians in Malta to review their own supervisory practices. The report’s recommendation for NCAs to monitor growth in authorisation applications suggests that future licensing activity may be subject to tighter oversight, which could slow the pace of new entrants seeking MiCA licences across the EU.

Why it matters

The ESMA peer‑review underscores the challenges NCAs face in applying MiCA’s uniform standards to novel crypto‑asset service providers. By highlighting that the MFSA only partially met expectations in authorising a CASP, the report signals that even jurisdictions with strong expertise may struggle with the detailed assessment of material risks at the licensing stage. This matters because consistent and rigorous authorisation processes are essential for protecting investors and ensuring market stability under MiCA. The PRC’s recommendations for closer monitoring of pending issues and timely supervisory adjustments aim to foster convergence among NCAs, reducing regulatory arbitrage and enhancing the credibility of the EU’s crypto framework. If Malta and other NCAs adopt the suggested improvements, the overall resilience of the European crypto ecosystem could be strengthened, supporting the EU’s ambition to become a leading hub for digital assets.

DeFi Intel’s take

Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.

DeFi Intel's take: The ESMA peer‑review suggests that Malta’s licensing framework, while staffed with expertise, still has gaps in handling pending material issues during CASP authorisation. We read this as a warning that the EU’s ambition for a harmonised crypto market may be hampered by uneven implementation across member states. The recommendation for NCAs to tighten monitoring could lead to more rigorous scrutiny of future MiCA licences, potentially slowing the entry of new custodians but improving investor protection. If the MFSA adopts the PRC’s advice, Malta could reinforce its reputation as a crypto‑friendly jurisdiction, yet the episode highlights the broader need for consistent supervisory standards across the EU.

Sources used for this analysis

DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.

Frequently asked questions

What did ESMA’s Peer Review Committee find about Malta’s MFSA?

The PRC found that the MFSA has good expertise and sufficient supervisory resources, fully meeting supervisory settings requirements and largely meeting supervisory review rules, but it only partially met expectations in the authorisation of a specific crypto‑asset service provider.

Why did the ESMA report not name the CASP involved?

The ESMA report did not disclose the identity of the CASP, stating that without knowing the exact unresolved issues it is hard to comment on potential impacts, and the regulator chose to keep the name confidential.

What recommendations did ESMA give to NCAs after the review?

ESMA recommended that all NCAs closely monitor growth in authorisation applications, assess material issues pending at the date of authorisation, and adjust supervisory practices in a timely manner to address the novelty and risks of CASPs.

Direct answers

Short answers, written to be quoted.

Did Malta’s MFSA fully comply with MiCA licensing requirements?
The MFSA fully met supervisory settings requirements but only partially met expectations in the authorisation of a specific crypto‑asset service provider, according to ESMA’s peer‑review.
What did ESMA recommend after the MFSA review?
ESMA recommended that NCAs closely monitor growth in authorisation applications, assess pending material issues, and adjust supervisory practices promptly to address the novelty and risks of CASPs.
Read full article on Gnews_mica →

DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Gnews_mica.

Entities in this story

Discussion

Comments are reviewed before publication.

No comments yet.

Want the full article?

Continue reading on Gnews_mica →

Stay current on entity-tagged crypto news

Get the weekly DeFi Intel brief — entity-graph intelligence covering protocols, tokens and incidents, free to your inbox.