DeFi Intel

A secret 11th-hour CLARITY proposal to protect crypto coders

A secret 11th-hour CLARITY proposal to protect crypto coders was just ripped apart by both sides of Washington

TL;DR

France’s National Assembly narrowly approved Amendment I‑3898, which would tax crypto‑to‑stablecoin swaps and adopt a weighted‑average cost basis. The change signals tighter crypto tax rules and could affect trading behavior ahead of the 2027 Finance Bill.

On October 16, France’s National Assembly approved Amendment I‑3898 by a razor‑thin margin of 38 votes to 37, with 25 members abstaining. The amendment would make the conversion of cryptocurrencies into stablecoins a taxable event and introduce a weighted‑average cost basis for calculating gains. The proposal, introduced by MP Nicolas Sansu as committee amendment I‑CF1826, still requires approval in the upcoming vote on the first part of the 2027 Finance Bill before it can become law.

Background

France has been navigating a complex regulatory landscape for digital assets, where current rules exempt crypto‑to‑stablecoin swaps from taxation. Lawmakers have been debating a suite of measures aimed at tightening reporting and tax obligations for crypto holders. Alongside Amendment I‑3898, the Assembly considered a proposal to allow investors to carry forward realised crypto losses for a decade, which was overwhelmingly rejected with only 18 votes in favour and 75 against. Two additional amendments are under discussion: Amendment I‑CF1822 would extend the existing exit tax to crypto portfolios exceeding €800,000, potentially taxing unrealised gains when a taxpayer moves abroad; and Amendment I‑2701 would compel individuals to disclose holdings in self‑custodial wallets that surpass €100,000 in a tax year. These initiatives reflect a broader European trend of integrating crypto activities into traditional tax frameworks, aiming to close loopholes and ensure fiscal equity across emerging financial technologies.

What happened

According to the reporting on ambcrypto.com, the National Assembly voted on October 16 to adopt Amendment I‑3898, which originated as committee amendment I‑CF1826 introduced by MP Nicolas Sansu. The vote tally was 38 in favour, 37 against, and 25 abstentions, indicating a single‑vote margin. The amendment proposes that swapping Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies for stablecoins will trigger a taxable incidence, removing the previous exemption. It also seeks to change the method for calculating gains by applying a weighted‑average purchase cost for assets bought at multiple price points. The amendment is not yet law; the Assembly is scheduled to vote on the first part of the 2027 Finance Bill the following day, which will determine whether the tax treatment becomes effective. On the same day, a separate amendment that would have permitted the carry‑forward of realised crypto losses for ten years was defeated, receiving only 18 votes in favour against 75 opposed, with three abstentions. Additionally, two other proposals remain under consideration: Amendment I‑CF1822, targeting an exit tax on crypto holdings above €800,000 for expatriates, and Amendment I‑2701, which would require disclosure of self‑custodial wallet balances exceeding €100,000 in a given tax year.

Market impact

The immediate market reaction to the narrow passage of Amendment I‑3898 was muted, as the amendment has not yet become law and its implementation is tied to the 2027 Finance Bill vote. However, the prospect of taxable crypto‑to‑stablecoin swaps has prompted traders to reassess transaction strategies, potentially reducing the volume of such swaps in anticipation of future tax liabilities. The defeat of the loss‑carry‑forward amendment, with a 75‑to‑18 vote, signals limited legislative appetite for tax relief mechanisms, which could influence investor sentiment toward holding crypto assets in France. While no specific price movements or capital flows were detailed in the source, the voting numbers—38 for, 37 against, 25 abstaining on the tax amendment, and 75 against, 18 for, 3 abstaining on the loss‑carry‑forward proposal—highlight the tight division among lawmakers and suggest that future policy shifts may create uncertainty for market participants.

Why it matters

The amendment’s potential to tax crypto‑to‑stablecoin conversions represents a significant shift in French fiscal policy, moving from a tax‑free treatment to a regime where each swap could generate taxable income. This change could increase compliance costs for traders and affect the attractiveness of France as a hub for crypto activity, especially for those who rely on stablecoins for liquidity management. The weighted‑average cost basis provision may simplify gain calculations but also alters tax liabilities for investors with diversified purchase histories. The rejection of the loss‑carry‑forward amendment indicates that French legislators are less inclined to provide relief for crypto investors, which could deter long‑term holding strategies. Moreover, the pending amendments on exit taxes and wallet disclosures could further expand the tax net, compelling crypto holders to adopt more robust reporting practices and potentially influencing cross‑border capital flows as investors seek jurisdictions with more favorable regimes.

DeFi Intel’s take

Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.

DeFi Intel's take: the narrow approval of Amendment I‑3898 suggests that French lawmakers are increasingly willing to bring crypto transactions into the traditional tax fold, even if the measure is not yet law. The weighted‑average cost basis could streamline reporting, but the shift to taxing stablecoin swaps may dampen trading volume and push some activity offshore. The overwhelming defeat of the loss‑carry‑forward proposal signals limited appetite for investor-friendly tax relief, hinting that future proposals may face similar resistance. Together, these signals point to a tightening regulatory environment that could reshape how French crypto participants manage risk, liquidity, and compliance.

Sources used for this analysis

DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.

Frequently asked questions

What does Amendment I‑3898 propose regarding crypto‑to‑stablecoin swaps?

Amendment I‑3898 would make the conversion of cryptocurrencies into stablecoins a taxable event in France, removing the current exemption. It also introduces a weighted‑average purchase cost method for calculating gains on crypto assets sold or exchanged.

How did the National Assembly vote on the amendment?

The amendment passed by a single vote, with 38 members supporting it, 37 opposing, and 25 abstaining. This narrow margin highlights the divided stance among French lawmakers on crypto taxation.

What other crypto‑related proposals were considered on the same day?

Lawmakers rejected a proposal to allow a ten‑year carry‑forward of realised crypto losses (18 for, 75 against, 3 abstaining). Two other amendments are under review: one extending the exit tax to crypto holdings over €800,000 for expatriates, and another requiring disclosure of self‑custodial wallets exceeding €100,000 in a tax year.

Direct answers

Short answers, written to be quoted.

Are crypto losses allowed to be carried forward in France?
No, the proposal to allow a ten‑year carry‑forward of realised crypto losses was rejected, receiving only 18 votes in favour against 75 opposed.
Read full article on CryptoSlate →

DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at CryptoSlate.

Entities in this story

Discussion

Comments are reviewed before publication.

No comments yet.

Want the full article?

Continue reading on CryptoSlate →

Stay current on entity-tagged crypto news

Get the weekly DeFi Intel brief — entity-graph intelligence covering protocols, tokens and incidents, free to your inbox.