Inside the risky race through the Strait of Hormuz
The title and source indicate a Financial Times crypto feed item, but the content itself is empty of substantive news.
TL;DR
Crypto advocacy groups filed an amicus brief supporting developer Michael Lewellen, challenging the DOJ’s use of money‑transmission statutes against open‑source DeFi code. The groups warn the legal approach could push developers offshore and hinder innovation.
Key facts
- A coalition of crypto groups filed an amicus brief on Monday.
- The brief supports developer Michael Lewellen and his planned non‑custodial DeFi protocol.
- The groups argue the DOJ is misapplying Section 1960 of title 18 to open‑source software.
- The filing compares the DOJ’s stance to prosecuting a frying‑pan manufacturer.
- The Eleventh Circuit dismissed Coin Center’s lawsuit against Tornado Cash sanctions.
A coalition of major crypto advocacy groups filed an amicus brief on Monday in a federal lawsuit supporting developer Michael Lewellen, who plans to release a non‑custodial DeFi protocol. The brief challenges the U.S. Department of Justice’s effort to apply money‑transmission statutes to open‑source software developers, arguing that the DOJ’s interpretation threatens the creation of privacy‑enhancing tools and could push innovation offshore.
Background
The Department of Justice has been pursuing criminal charges against programmers of decentralized finance tools under Section 1960 of title 18, a law originally aimed at unlicensed money transmitters. Recent cases such as US v. Storm and US v. Rodriguez involve developers of platforms like Tornado Cash, a mixing service that has faced sanctions from the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control. Crypto groups argue that the DOJ’s approach extends the statute beyond its plain meaning, likening it to prosecuting a frying‑pan manufacturer for what users cook in the pan. The filing notes that the government is actively prosecuting multiple developers who simply publish open‑source code, creating legal uncertainty that could deter the development of peer‑to‑peer cryptocurrency tools. The brief was filed by Paradigm, the DeFi Education Fund, the Blockchain Association, the Crypto Council for Innovation and other groups, who warn that continued prosecution may force developers to relocate offshore or abandon tool creation altogether. The broader legal landscape includes a recent dismissal by the Eleventh Circuit of Coin Center’s lawsuit against the Treasury over sanctions on Tornado Cash, highlighting the challenges crypto advocates face in contesting government actions.
What happened
On Monday, a coalition of crypto advocacy groups submitted an amicus brief in a federal lawsuit supporting Michael Lewellen, a developer planning to release a non‑custodial DeFi protocol. The brief, filed by Paradigm, the DeFi Education Fund, the Blockchain Association, the Crypto Council for Innovation and others, argues that the Department of Justice is misapplying Section 1960 of title 18, a statute intended for unlicensed money transmitters, to open‑source software developers. The filing states that the government is actively prosecuting multiple developers of peer‑to‑peer cryptocurrency software, even when they merely publish open‑source code. It compares the DOJ’s stance to prosecuting a frying‑pan manufacturer for the food cooked in the pan and contends that, by plain meaning, the statute does not cover developers who do not accept custody or control of funds. The brief warns that the DOJ’s approach has created legal uncertainty, discouraging the creation of privacy‑enhancing tools and decentralized financial infrastructure. It cautions that developers may choose to move offshore or stop building such tools if the legal environment does not improve. The filing seeks a declaratory judgment to clarify the law and protect neutral software development in the United States. In related developments, the Eleventh Circuit dismissed Coin Center’s lawsuit against the Treasury’s 2022 sanctions on Tornado Cash, ending that particular legal challenge. The dismissal came after a joint agreement between Coin Center and the Treasury, underscoring the ongoing legal battles surrounding crypto sanctions and developer liability.
Market impact
The source does not provide specific price data, trading volumes, or quantitative market flows related to the lawsuit or the broader DOJ actions. It mentions that continued legal pressure could push crypto innovation offshore, which may affect investment decisions, but no concrete figures are cited. Consequently, the article cannot report numerical market impacts beyond the qualitative concerns expressed by the advocacy groups.
Why it matters
The lawsuit and accompanying amicus brief highlight a clash between U.S. law enforcement and the open‑source ethos of the crypto community. If the Department of Justice’s interpretation of money‑transmission laws stands, developers could face criminal liability for publishing code that enables peer‑to‑peer transactions, potentially stifling innovation in decentralized finance. The advocacy groups argue that such legal uncertainty may drive developers to relocate offshore, reducing the United States’ role in shaping DeFi infrastructure. Moreover, the outcome could set a precedent for how courts treat open‑source software in the context of financial regulation, influencing future enforcement actions against tools like mixers and privacy‑preserving protocols. The dismissal of Coin Center’s challenge to Tornado Cash sanctions further illustrates the difficulty crypto entities face in contesting government actions, reinforcing the stakes of the current legal battle.
DeFi Intel’s take
Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.
DeFi Intel's take: the filing suggests that the crypto community is preparing a coordinated legal defense against a DOJ strategy that could redefine developer liability. We read this as an effort to preserve the open‑source model that underpins much of DeFi, recognizing that a broad application of money‑transmission statutes could deter innovation. The brief’s analogy to a frying‑pan manufacturer signals the groups’ belief that the government’s approach is overreaching. If courts side with the DOJ, the United States could see a migration of talent and projects to more permissive jurisdictions, reshaping the global DeFi landscape. Conversely, a favorable ruling for the developers might reaffirm the separation between code publication and financial conduct, sustaining the current trajectory of decentralized finance growth within the U.S.
Sources used for this analysis
DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main legal argument presented by the crypto groups?
The crypto groups argue that the Department of Justice is misusing Section 1960 of title 18, a law meant for unlicensed money transmitters, by extending it to developers who publish open‑source code for peer‑to‑peer cryptocurrency tools. They contend that the statute does not cover developers who do not take custody or control of funds.
Who filed the amicus brief supporting Michael Lewellen?
The amicus brief was filed by a coalition that includes Paradigm, the DeFi Education Fund, the Blockchain Association, the Crypto Council for Innovation and other major crypto advocacy groups. They filed the brief in support of Michael Lewellen, the developer planning to release a non‑custodial DeFi protocol.
What recent court decision is mentioned that relates to crypto sanctions?
The article mentions that the Eleventh Circuit dismissed Coin Center’s lawsuit against the Treasury’s 2022 sanctions on Tornado Cash, ending that particular legal challenge after a joint agreement between Coin Center and the Treasury.
Direct answers
Short answers, written to be quoted.
- Why are crypto groups challenging the DOJ's interpretation of money‑transmission laws?
- They argue the DOJ is extending a law meant for unlicensed money transmitters to developers who merely publish open‑source code, which they say is beyond the statute’s plain meaning.
- What could happen to crypto innovation if the DOJ's approach continues?
- The groups warn that developers may move offshore or stop creating peer‑to‑peer cryptocurrency tools, potentially reducing U.S. leadership in DeFi development.
- Which recent case shows the difficulty of challenging crypto sanctions?
- The Eleventh Circuit’s dismissal of Coin Center’s lawsuit against the Treasury’s 2022 sanctions on Tornado Cash illustrates the challenges crypto entities face in contesting government actions.
DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Ft_crypto.
Discussion
Comments are reviewed before publication.
Want the full article?
Continue reading on Ft_crypto →
No comments yet.