DeFi Intel

Bitcoin Is its Most Affordable in Two Years. Which ETF Is Better to Invest With Now: iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF or VanEck Bitcoin ETF?

Bitcoin is at its most affordable level in two years and asks which ETF is better to invest in now: the iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF or the VanEck Bitcoin ETF.

TL;DR

A seed‑generation flaw in Coldcard's 2021 firmware enabled attackers to steal roughly 714.8 BTC, now valued at over $115 million. The long‑running theft underscores critical security risks in hardware wallets.

Key facts

  • Coldcard firmware with a seed‑generation flaw was released on 17 March 2021.
  • Total stolen Bitcoin exceeds 1,596 BTC, valued at over $100 million.

A Coldcard firmware flaw released on 17 March 2021 triggered a multi‑year Bitcoin theft campaign that resurfaced in July 2026. Galaxy Research interviewed more than 200 victims, revealing that 192 individuals lost roughly 714.8 BTC, now valued at over $115 million as of mid‑August 2026. The exploit, linked to a seed‑generation weakness, allowed attackers to predict or forge wallet seeds and siphon funds from compromised addresses, many of which were created on the day the vulnerable firmware launched.

Background

The Coldcard hardware wallet, popular among security‑focused Bitcoin users, introduced a firmware update on 17 March 2021 that unintentionally contained a seed‑generation flaw. This flaw made it possible for malicious actors to predict the entropy used to create wallet seeds, effectively granting them the ability to recreate private keys and steal funds. The vulnerability went unnoticed for years, allowing a coordinated theft operation that targeted addresses created during the firmware’s initial release. Between 2021 and 2022, the campaign reached its peak, with the largest concentration of stolen addresses observed in that period. Galaxy Research later compiled a dataset of 8,680 addresses linked to the theft, of which only a small fraction could be directly tied to victims who reported losses. Despite the limited direct reporting, the addresses in the dataset collectively held about 1,778.6 BTC. The attackers employed sophisticated transaction patterns, using specific block timings, fee structures, lock times, and RBF settings to obscure their movements. Their methods included batching multiple victims into single transactions and dispersing stolen funds across a wide array of destination addresses, complicating forensic analysis. The ongoing impact of the exploit was still being felt in July 2026, more than five years after the vulnerable firmware’s release, highlighting the long‑term risks associated with hardware wallet security flaws.

What happened

On 17 March 2021, Coldcard released firmware that contained a seed‑generation flaw, allowing attackers to predict wallet seed entropy. The exploit began stealing Bitcoin on 30 July 2021, as reported by Galaxy Research. By 16 August 2026, Galaxy had spoken to over 200 victims to understand the attack’s intelligence. The compromised coins were produced on the day the vulnerable firmware was released, linking the theft directly to the flaw. An assessment showed that between 2021 and 2022 the largest concentration of stolen addresses occurred, with 192 individuals reporting losses involving roughly 714.8 BTC. Galaxy’s published theft set includes 8,680 addresses, holding about 1,778.6 BTC, though only a small percentage have been directly connected to victims. AMBCrypto reported that the total losses surpassed 1,596 BTC, valued at more than $100 million across roughly 7,300 addresses. With Bitcoin’s price on 16 August 2026, the losses exceeded $115 million. Investigators identified attacker fingerprints based on transaction behavior such as block timing, fees, lock times, RBF/sequence settings, transaction structure, and destination addresses. Wave 1 stole roughly 1,082.65 BTC from blocks 960,183–960,191, moving one victim per transaction into four collection addresses. Wave 2 handled 19 victims, while Wave 3 managed 63 victims. A pattern labeled Footprint E batched up to 795 victims per transaction, with a median of 118, dispersing funds either over hundreds of locations or concentrating them into a few addresses.

Market impact

The theft of approximately 714.8 BTC translates to more than $115 million at Bitcoin’s price on 16 August 2026, according to the source. AMBCrypto’s estimate of 1,596 BTC stolen, valued at over $100 million, underscores the scale of the financial loss. The compromised addresses, numbering around 1,790 in the public dataset, collectively held roughly 714.8 BTC, indicating a significant concentration of value in vulnerable wallets. The ongoing fallout has likely influenced market sentiment around hardware wallet security, potentially affecting demand for alternative solutions. While the source does not provide specific price movements, the magnitude of the loss—exceeding $115 million—suggests heightened scrutiny of wallet firmware updates and may prompt investors to reassess risk exposure in Bitcoin holdings tied to hardware wallets.

Why it matters

The Coldcard exploit demonstrates how a firmware flaw can enable a prolonged, large‑scale theft of cryptocurrency, affecting hundreds of users and resulting in losses exceeding $115 million. The ability of attackers to predict seed entropy undermines the fundamental security premise of hardware wallets, which are marketed as the gold standard for private key protection. The discovery of sophisticated transaction fingerprints, such as specific block timings and RBF settings, shows the attackers’ advanced operational capabilities, complicating forensic tracing and recovery efforts. The continued relevance of the exploit five years after its inception highlights the importance of rigorous firmware auditing and rapid patch deployment. Moreover, the incident may erode confidence in hardware wallet solutions, prompting users and institutions to seek alternative custody methods or demand higher assurance standards from manufacturers.

DeFi Intel’s take

Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.

DeFi Intel's take: the Coldcard episode suggests that even well‑regarded hardware wallets can harbor deep, exploitable flaws that persist for years, exposing users to multi‑million‑dollar losses. We read this as a warning that the security of seed generation processes must be continuously validated, especially when firmware updates are rolled out. The scale of the theft, with over $115 million lost, indicates that attackers can orchestrate sophisticated, long‑term campaigns that evade detection. This event may push the market toward greater scrutiny of hardware wallet code and could accelerate interest in decentralized custody solutions that do not rely on single points of failure.

Sources used for this analysis

DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.

Frequently asked questions

When was the Coldcard firmware flaw first introduced?

The vulnerable Coldcard firmware was released on 17 March 2021, and the exploit began stealing Bitcoin on 30 July 2021, according to the source.

How many Bitcoin were reported lost due to the Coldcard exploit?

The source states that 192 individuals reported losses involving roughly 714.8 BTC, and AMBCrypto reported total stolen amounts exceeding 1,596 BTC, valued at over $100 million.

What methods did attackers use to hide their transactions?

Investigators identified fingerprints such as specific block timing, fee structures, lock times, RBF/sequence settings, transaction structures, and varied destination addresses, with some waves batching many victims per transaction.

Direct answers

Short answers, written to be quoted.

What caused the Coldcard Bitcoin theft?
The theft was caused by a seed‑generation flaw in Coldcard's firmware released on 17 March 2021, allowing attackers to predict wallet seeds and steal funds.
Read full article on Gnews_bitcoin →

DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Gnews_bitcoin.

Entities in this story

Discussion

Comments are reviewed before publication.

No comments yet.

Want the full article?

Continue reading on Gnews_bitcoin →

Stay current on entity-tagged crypto news

Get the weekly DeFi Intel brief — entity-graph intelligence covering protocols, tokens and incidents, free to your inbox.