ESMA targets MiCA crypto custodians with resilience review
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has launched a supervisory review of MiCA-authorized crypto custodians. The review shifts ESMA's focus from licensing to testing how firms handle operational risks in practice. The provided text is truncated and does not include further details from the regulator.
TL;DR
ESMA’s peer‑review on 11 July 2026 found Malta’s MFSA only partially met MiCA authorisation expectations for a crypto service provider, while the EU’s MiCA framework shows 39 e‑money tokens authorised and zero asset‑referenced tokens, with firms facing significant compliance costs. The findings signal tighter supervisory scrutiny and possible regulatory adjustments.
Key facts
- The MFSA was judged to have only partially met expectations for authorising a specific CASP.
- MiCA became effective on 29 June 2024, with stable‑coin rules on 30 June 2024 and CASP licensing on 30 December 2024.
- As of 1 September 2026, 39 e‑money tokens are authorised under MiCA.
- Zero asset‑referenced tokens have been authorised under MiCA as of the same date.
- Capital requirements under MiCA range from €50,000 to €150,000 depending on service class.
- Compliance costs for firms are projected in the tens to hundreds of thousands of euros annually, with larger firms potentially facing million‑euro bills.
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) released a peer‑review report on Thursday that found Malta’s Financial Services Authority (MFSA) only “partially met expectations” in the MiCA authorisation of a crypto‑asset service provider (CASP). The assessment, carried out by ESMA’s ad‑hoc Peer Review Committee, highlighted shortfalls in the authorisation process while noting that the MFSA’s supervisory set‑up and staffing were largely satisfactory. The review follows a broader EU effort to ensure consistent MiCA implementation across national competent authorities.
Background
The Markets in Crypto‑Assets Regulation (MiCA) became effective on 29 June 2024, establishing a unified legal framework for crypto activities across the European Union. MiCA introduced a phased rollout, with stable‑coin rules taking effect on 30 June 2024 and the broader licensing regime for crypto‑asset service providers (CASPs) commencing on 30 December 2024. The regulation aims to give firms a single licence that can be “passported” across all member states, creating a market of roughly 450 million consumers. In December 2024 the European Banking Authority’s Board of Supervisors agreed on a coordinated approach for CASP authorisations, and in April 2025 ESMA’s Board of Supervisors launched a peer‑review of the MFSA’s handling of a specific CASP authorisation. The review was intended to foster supervisory convergence among national competent authorities (NCAs). Meanwhile, the European Commission has been running a public consultation on MiCA since May 2026, gathering feedback on market access, compliance costs and the apparent lack of authorised asset‑referenced tokens. The consultation deadline has been extended to 30 September 2026, with the Commission expected to produce a report by June 2027 that could lead to legislative amendments.
What happened
ESMA’s ad‑hoc Peer Review Committee (PRC) published its findings on 11 July 2026, focusing on three areas: supervisory settings and resources, the authorisation process, and supervisory review and use of powers. The PRC noted that the MFSA has built a “good level of expertise” and possesses sufficient supervisory resources for CASP authorisations, fully meeting supervisory‑settings requirements and largely meeting supervisory‑review rules. However, the committee concluded that the MFSA only “partially met expectations” regarding the authorisation of the specific, unnamed CASP, recommending that the regulator assess material issues that were pending at the date of authorisation or not adequately considered. The report also urged all EU NCAs to closely monitor the growth in authorisation applications and to adjust supervisory practices promptly, given the novelty and inherent risks of CASPs. The ESMA review did not disclose whether any licences would be revoked or re‑evaluated. Commentators such as Nathan Catania of XReg consulting suggested that revocation is unlikely, though the lack of detail makes definitive conclusions difficult. Parallel to the ESMA review, the European Commission’s consultation on MiCA, launched on 20 May 2026, has gathered industry and public feedback, highlighting that as of 1 September 2026 there are 39 e‑money tokens authorised under MiCA and zero asset‑referenced tokens, and that compliance costs for firms range from tens to hundreds of thousands of euros annually, with larger operators potentially facing million‑euro bills. The European Banking Authority added recommendations on 24 September 2026 to strengthen rules around multi‑issuer stablecoins, signalling ongoing regulatory refinement.
Market impact
The MiCA framework, now in its second year of operation, shows mixed uptake. As of 1 September 2026, 39 e‑money tokens have been issued under MiCA, while no asset‑referenced tokens have received authorisation, suggesting a gap in that segment of the market. Capital requirements under MiCA vary from €50,000 for firms offering basic Class 1 services to €150,000 for Class 3 operators such as trading platforms. Ongoing compliance costs are projected to run in the tens to hundreds of thousands of euros per year for most firms, with larger operations potentially facing costs in the millions. These cost structures are already influencing business decisions, as firms weigh the benefits of a single EU licence against the financial burden of meeting capital and reporting obligations. The ESMA peer‑review itself may prompt MFSA‑licensed firms to reassess internal processes, potentially leading to increased spending on compliance resources. Meanwhile, the European Commission’s consultation, extended to 30 September 2026, signals that further regulatory adjustments could alter cost expectations, especially if the Commission decides to tighten rules around multi‑issuer stablecoins as recommended by the European Banking Authority.
Why it matters
The ESMA review underscores the challenges of achieving supervisory convergence across EU member states, a core objective of MiCA. By highlighting that the MFSA only partially met authorisation expectations, the report signals to other NCAs that gaps in authorisation diligence can attract scrutiny, prompting them to tighten their own processes. This could lead to a more uniform application of MiCA standards, reducing regulatory arbitrage and enhancing investor protection. At the same time, the European Commission’s consultation reveals that the MiCA regime is already imposing significant compliance costs on firms, with the lack of authorised asset‑referenced tokens indicating a possible market hesitation or regulatory bottleneck. If the Commission’s forthcoming report recommends amendments, firms may face either eased compliance burdens or stricter rules, both of which would reshape the competitive landscape for crypto service providers operating in the EU. Together, the ESMA peer‑review and the Commission’s feedback loop illustrate a regulatory ecosystem that is still calibrating its approach, with direct implications for licensing, market entry, and the overall attractiveness of the EU as a crypto hub.
DeFi Intel’s take
Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.
DeFi Intel's take: the ESMA peer‑review suggests that the EU is moving from a broad‑brush licensing model toward a more granular supervisory regime, where national authorities will be expected to demonstrate full compliance with authorisation standards. The fact that the MFSA’s shortcomings were identified without naming the CASP indicates a cautious approach, aiming to correct systemic issues without destabilising individual licences. Coupled with the European Commission’s consultation, which highlights high compliance costs and a zero count of authorised asset‑referenced tokens, we read this as a signal that MiCA’s implementation may be tightening, especially around stable‑coin structures. Firms that have already invested in robust compliance frameworks may gain a competitive edge, while those still adapting could face higher costs or delayed market entry. The overall trajectory points to a more disciplined EU crypto market, but one where the cost of entry and ongoing compliance will be decisive factors for success.
Sources used for this analysis
- cointelegraph.com/news/mica-regulator-alarm-malta-crypto-licensing-process
- cryptobriefing.com/european-commission-mica-review-compliance/
DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.
Frequently asked questions
What did ESMA find about Malta’s MFSA authorisation process?
ESMA’s Peer Review Committee reported that the MFSA fully met supervisory‑settings requirements and largely met supervisory‑review rules, but only partially met expectations for the authorisation of a specific, unnamed crypto‑asset service provider. The PRC recommended that the MFSA assess material issues pending at the time of authorisation.
How many e‑money tokens and asset‑referenced tokens are authorised under MiCA?
As of 1 September 2026, there are 39 e‑money tokens issued under MiCA and zero authorised asset‑referenced tokens, indicating that the stable‑coin segment that relies on baskets of assets has not yet received any licences.
What are the capital and compliance cost requirements for MiCA‑licensed firms?
MiCA sets capital requirements ranging from €50,000 for basic Class 1 service providers to €150,000 for Class 3 operators such as trading platforms. Ongoing compliance costs are projected to run in the tens to hundreds of thousands of euros annually, with larger firms potentially facing costs in the millions.
Direct answers
Short answers, written to be quoted.
- Why did ESMA say Malta’s MFSA only partially met expectations?
- ESMA’s Peer Review Committee said the MFSA partially met expectations because material issues pending at the date of authorisation were not adequately considered, prompting a recommendation to assess those issues.
- What is the current state of asset‑referenced token authorisations under MiCA?
- As of 1 September 2026, no asset‑referenced tokens have been authorised under MiCA, indicating that this segment of the regulation has not yet produced licensed tokens.
DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Crypto_news_dot.
Entities in this story
Discussion
Comments are reviewed before publication.
Want the full article?
Continue reading on Crypto_news_dot →
No comments yet.