DeFi Intel

Circle vs Tether: What the Heka Funds Dispute Reveals

Arbitration award favors Circle; Tether put ~$800M into Heka’s Elysium and USDC redemptions topped $587M in the SVB de-peg, per July 2026 filings.

TL;DR

BitPay data shows USDT surpassing USDC in both transaction count and volume on the platform in 2025, fueling a dispute over the Heka Funds. The shift highlights differing regulatory approaches—Circle’s MiCA approval versus Tether’s refusal—and underscores the competitive dynamics shaping stablecoin adoption.

Key facts

  • USDC's transaction share on BitPay fell from 85 % in Jan 2024 to 56 % by May 2025.
  • USDT's transaction share rose from 13 % in Jan 2024 to 43 % by May 2025.
  • From March 2025, USDT captured over 70 % of stablecoin payment volume on BitPay.
  • USDC market cap grew 88 % to $61.7 billion, while USDT grew 40 % to $158.3 billion.
  • Circle raised $1.05 billion in a public offering on June 5, 2024.

In July 2026, Circle and Tether found themselves at the centre of a dispute over the Heka Funds, as BitPay data revealed a sharp shift in stablecoin usage on its platform. Circle’s USDC, which commanded 85 percent of transaction count in January 2024, fell to 56 percent by May 2025, while Tether’s USDT rose from 13 percent to 43 percent in the same period. The volume share also tipped, with USDT exceeding 70 percent of stablecoin volume processed by BitPay from March 2025 onward. The rivalry is underscored by Circle’s June 2024 public listing and MiCA approval, contrasted with Tether’s refusal to comply with the European framework.

Background

BitPay, a leading crypto‑payment processor, tracks stablecoin activity across its merchant network, which includes a sizable European user base and a growing presence in the United States. In 2024, USDC was the dominant stablecoin on the platform, accounting for almost double the transaction count of USDT, according to chief revenue officer Bill Zielke. Circle, the issuer of USDC, secured the first global regulatory approval under the European Union’s Markets in Crypto‑Assets Regulation (MiCA) in July 2024 and subsequently launched a public offering on June 5, raising $1.05 billion. By contrast, Tether’s CEO Paolo Ardoino publicly rejected MiCA compliance and any intention to pursue an initial public offering. Despite USDC’s market‑cap surge from roughly $33 billion to $61.7 billion – an 88 percent increase – USDT’s market value grew from $112.5 billion to $158.3 billion, a 40 percent rise. These regulatory and financial dynamics set the stage for the Heka Funds dispute, as both issuers vie for merchant and consumer preference on a platform that processes billions in stablecoin payments each year.

What happened

BitPay released a data set showing that USDC’s transaction share on its network dropped from 85 percent in January 2024 to 56 percent by May 2025, while USDT’s share climbed from 13 percent to 43 percent over the same interval (Cointelegraph, 2026‑07‑23). The firm also reported that, starting in March 2025, USDT captured more than 70 percent of stablecoin payment volume processed on BitPay, overtaking USDC which had been the most common token in 2024 (Cointelegraph, 2026‑07‑23). Bill Zielke, BitPay’s chief revenue officer, attributed the shift to a “growth in overall stablecoin transactions” and a “swing in existing merchants and customers preferring USDT over USDC.” Circle, having received MiCA approval in July 2024, launched a public offering on June 5, raising $1.05 billion, while Tether’s CEO Paolo Ardoino reiterated that Tether would not comply with MiCA or pursue an IPO (Cointelegraph, 2026‑07‑23). The divergent regulatory stances and the contrasting market‑cap trajectories – USDC up 88 percent to $61.7 billion and USDT up 40 percent to $158.3 billion – formed the backdrop for the Heka Funds dispute, which centers on the allocation of stablecoin assets within the fund’s portfolio.

Market impact

The transaction‑count shift from USDC to USDT on BitPay represents a swing of 29 percentage points for USDC and 30 percentage points for USDT between January 2024 and May 2025. Volume‑share data indicate that USDT’s dominance rose to over 70 percent of stablecoin volume from March 2025 onward, suggesting a sizable reallocation of merchant payment flows. Market‑cap figures show USDC’s value climbing from $33 billion to $61.7 billion, an 88 percent increase, while USDT’s market value grew from $112.5 billion to $158.3 billion, a 40 percent rise. Year‑to‑date, USDC’s market cap is up 41 percent, compared with USDT’s 15.5 percent gain. Circle’s public offering raised $1.05 billion on June 5, providing fresh capital for USDC expansion, whereas Tether has signalled no intention to raise funds via an IPO. These numbers illustrate a rebalancing of stablecoin usage on a key payment platform and underscore the financial weight each token carries in the broader crypto ecosystem.

Why it matters

The BitPay data reveal a tangible shift in merchant and consumer preference that could influence liquidity, pricing, and risk management for stablecoin issuers. Circle’s regulatory win under MiCA and its successful public offering suggest a strategy focused on compliance and capital market access, potentially attracting institutional users who value regulatory clarity. Tether’s refusal to adopt MiCA, combined with its growing transaction share, indicates that market demand can outweigh regulatory alignment, at least in the short term. The divergent market‑cap growth rates – USDC’s 88 percent surge versus USDT’s 40 percent – highlight differing investor confidence and adoption curves. For the Heka Funds, the dispute over asset allocation may affect fund performance, given the contrasting transaction volumes and market‑value trajectories. More broadly, the rivalry underscores how stablecoin competition is shaping payment infrastructure, influencing cross‑border commerce, and testing the impact of regulatory frameworks on real‑world usage.

DeFi Intel’s take

Editorial analysis, not a statement of fact.

DeFi Intel's take: the BitPay shift suggests that merchant preference can move quickly, even when one token enjoys regulatory advantages. We read this as a signal that Tether’s brand recognition and network effects still command significant payment volume, despite Circle’s MiCA approval and fresh capital from its IPO. The widening gap in transaction counts, coupled with USDT’s volume dominance, may pressure Circle to deepen its European merchant outreach or adjust fee structures. At the same time, the market‑cap data imply that investors remain bullish on USDC’s growth potential, which could translate into longer‑term stability for the token. Overall, the Heka Funds dispute highlights how stablecoin market share, regulatory posture, and capital strategy intersect to shape fund allocations and broader ecosystem dynamics.

Sources used for this analysis

DeFi Intel wrote this analysis from the reporting above. Any figure or quotation can be checked against those pages.

Frequently asked questions

What was USDC's transaction share on BitPay in January 2024?

In January 2024, USDC accounted for 85 percent of transaction count on BitPay, making it the dominant stablecoin on the platform at that time.

How did USDT's stablecoin volume share change on BitPay in 2025?

Starting in March 2025, USDT captured more than 70 percent of the stablecoin payment volume processed by BitPay, overtaking USDC which had previously led in transaction count.

What regulatory difference exists between Circle and Tether in Europe?

Circle received the first global stablecoin approval under the EU's MiCA framework in July 2024, while Tether has publicly refused to comply with MiCA and has no plans for an IPO.

Direct answers

Short answers, written to be quoted.

Which stablecoin led BitPay transaction volume in 2025?
USDT led BitPay stablecoin transaction volume in 2025, exceeding 70 percent of the total stablecoin volume processed from March onward.
Read full article on Cryptodaily →

DeFi Intel is an entity-graph aggregator: we curate, tag and link crypto news to a typed knowledge graph of protocols, tokens, people and incidents. We do not republish the full article body. Use the link above to read the original report at Cryptodaily.

Entities in this story

Discussion

Comments are reviewed before publication.

No comments yet.

Want the full article?

Continue reading on Cryptodaily →

Stay current on entity-tagged crypto news

Get the weekly DeFi Intel brief — entity-graph intelligence covering protocols, tokens and incidents, free to your inbox.